Independent agency licensed in MD, DC, VA, DE, IL & FL Contact Andrew 410-996-4757

HomeGuidesFirst renewal and escrow

Your first homeowners insurance renewal in Maryland: why your mortgage payment can go up, and what to check

About a year after you buy a home, two things happen at around the same time: your homeowners policy comes up for its first renewal, and your mortgage servicer runs its first annual review of your escrow account. Together they can raise your monthly payment by more than the premium increase itself. Here's what to look for, why the payment moves and what you can do about it.

The short version

  • At least 45 days before renewal, your insurer has to send you your old and new premium, even if nothing changed. That's your cue to shop.
  • If you have escrow, your servicer resets your payment once a year. A premium increase gets spread over 12 months, and a catch-up amount can be added on top.
  • For a shortage of one month's escrow payment or more, your servicer can't make you pay a lump sum.
  • You can change insurers even if your mortgage company pays the bill. Don't cancel the old policy until the new one is in effect, and get proof of the new policy to your servicer.
  • In Maryland, your credit history can't be the reason your homeowners premium went up.

What shows up before your renewal

Maryland requires your insurer to send you a notice at least 45 days before renewal showing your premium at the start of the current term, your premium now if it has changed, and your renewal premium. It has to go out even if the premium is flat, and the law has no exception for policies your mortgage company pays, so watch your mail and email for it.

Two more things to look for in that packet:

  • A higher coverage limit. If your policy automatically raises your coverage for inflation or construction costs, your insurer has to tell you at least 45 days ahead, with the type of coverage and the dollar change. Higher limits generally mean a higher premium.
  • Anything reduced. A cut in coverage or a higher deductible takes the same 45 days' notice.

The notice has to show the numbers, but I haven't found a Maryland rule that makes it explain a homeowners increase. The Maryland Insurance Administration (MIA) says that if the notice doesn't tie the increase to a claim, it's usually a general rate increase.

Why the premium can go up

The MIA doesn't set your rate. Insurers file their rates with it and can usually use them without prior approval. It points to rising repair, materials and labor costs, more storm claims, and policies adjusting the dwelling coverage limit. Its 2024 survey also found that many insurers have started inspecting homes before renewal, and that out-of-date maintenance was the top reason for non-renewal.

Maryland also rules some reasons out. An insurer can't rate your homeowners policy based on your credit history. It can't raise your premium because of a question you asked that didn't lead to a paid claim. And at renewal, it can't raise your homeowners premium because of an auto claim.

Insurers usually don't break an increase down. On one Maryland home bought in 2025, the first renewal went up about 12%, or about $250 a year, and the renewal papers didn't say why. On another home, the premium rose about 27% while the insurer's own rebuild estimate rose about 3%. So don't assume your coverage went up along with your price.

Why your mortgage payment moves

If your payment includes escrow, it goes up or down when your premium or property taxes do. Your servicer has to review the account at the end of each escrow year and send you a statement within 30 days. The first one usually comes a little over a year after closing.

The new monthly amount is one-twelfth of what the servicer expects to pay over the next year, plus a cushion of up to two months. If the account won't reach the balance it needs, that's a shortage, and repaying it can be added on top.

That's why a modest premium increase can look bigger on your statement. Here's an example I worked out using the method in the federal rules: a $3,000 tax bill, a renewal $360 above the $1,800 estimate, and the full two-month cushion.

PeriodMonthly escrow payment
Year one$400.00
Next 12 months$457.50: $30 more for the higher premium, plus $27.50 to repay a $330 shortage
After that$430.00

Your statement will differ. In the same exercise with no taxes in the account, the payment went up $67.50 for the year, then settled $30 above where it started. Property taxes can move your escrow too, so read both lines before you blame the insurer.

What your servicer can and can't do

  • Shortage under one month's escrow payment. It can leave it alone, ask you to repay it within 30 days, or spread it over at least 12 months.
  • Shortage of one month's payment or more. It can leave it alone or spread it over at least 12 months. It can't require a lump sum or offer one on the statement, though it may accept one you choose to send. Paying early removes the catch-up amount, not the higher monthly amount for the new premium.
  • Deficiency. If the account has actually gone negative, it can collect that in as few as two payments.
  • Surplus. If the account has $50 or more extra and you're current, it has to refund that within 30 days.
  • Paying the bill. It has to pay your premium on time and advance the money if the account is short, as long as you're not more than 30 days overdue.

What you can do about the premium

  • Check your dwelling coverage. It should reflect what it would cost to rebuild your home, not what you paid for it. Ask your insurer or agent to run an updated estimate. If the limit is too high, the MIA notes, your premium will be too high. If it's too low, you may not have enough to rebuild.
  • Ask about discounts, including for home features and for having more than one policy with the insurer.
  • Consider a higher deductible, after checking whether your loan limits it.
  • Shop it. The MIA says the best time is well before you renew, and to compare policies with the same coverage.

How to switch when your mortgage company pays

The MIA is clear that you can: even if your premium is part of your mortgage payment, you have the right to choose your insurer. Here's the order that keeps you covered.

  1. Compare at the same coverage, with your current policy in front of you.
  2. Check your mortgage company's requirements. Some want advance notice of a change in insurers, so ask its insurance department.
  3. Start the new policy first. The MIA's advice is plain: don't cancel your policy until a replacement is in effect.
  4. Send proof to your servicer, such as the new declarations page. Under the federal rules, if you tell your servicer you cancelled and it hasn't heard about other coverage, that gives it a reasonable basis to believe your policy is gone.
  5. Then cancel the old policy yourself, and check your next escrow statement for the new premium.

Your servicer may pay the renewal weeks ahead of the date. On one policy I handled, it was set to pay three weeks early. If the old insurer has already been paid when you switch, that money isn't lost: the homeowners policies I've read refund the unused premium, and most of them say pro rata, though your policy controls. Ask who the refund will go to. If it comes to you, ask your servicer about putting it back into escrow, because otherwise it can show up as a shortage.

The thing to avoid is a gap. If your servicer believes you have no coverage, it can buy force-placed insurance and charge you for it, after a notice at least 45 days before charging and a reminder at least 15 days before. The MIA warns that it often costs substantially more and protects only the lender's interest. If that happens, send proof of your coverage. Your servicer then has 15 days to cancel it and refund any overlap.

If you need to push back

Take premium questions to your insurer or agent first, then the MIA. The MIA will review a complaint, but you still pay the billed premium while it does, and if the increase is a properly filed general rate increase, it says there may be nothing it can require the insurer to do. Take escrow problems to your servicer in writing, then to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau or the Maryland Commissioner of Financial Regulation.

Frequently asked questions

Why did my mortgage payment go up after my home insurance renewed?

If your payment includes escrow, it changes when your premium or property taxes change. At its annual escrow analysis, your servicer resets the monthly amount to one-twelfth of what it expects to pay over the next year, plus a cushion of up to two months. If the account comes up short, it can add a catch-up amount on top, usually for 12 months, so the payment can rise by more than the premium increase alone.

Do I have to pay an escrow shortage all at once?

Not if the shortage is one month's escrow payment or more. Your servicer can leave it alone or spread it over at least 12 months, and it can't require a lump sum, though it may accept one you choose to send. If the shortage is less than one month's payment, it can also ask you to repay it within 30 days.

Can I switch homeowners insurance if my mortgage company pays the bill?

Yes. The Maryland Insurance Administration says you have the same rights as anyone who pays the insurer directly, though some mortgage companies require advance notice of a change. Don't cancel your old policy until the new one is in effect, and get proof of the new policy to your servicer.

What happens if my mortgage company already paid the old insurer?

Your policy controls, but the homeowners policies I've read refund the unused premium when you cancel. Ask who the refund will go to. If it comes to you, ask your servicer about putting it back into escrow, because otherwise it can show up as a shortage.

Does my insurer have to tell me why my homeowners premium went up?

It has to show you the numbers at least 45 days before renewal. I haven't found a Maryland rule that makes it explain a homeowners increase. The Maryland Insurance Administration says that if the notice doesn't tie the increase to a claim, it's usually a general rate increase. You can always ask your insurer or agent.

Can my credit raise my homeowners premium in Maryland?

No. Maryland doesn't let homeowners insurers rate a policy based on your credit history. It also bars a premium increase based on a question you asked your insurer that didn't lead to a paid claim, and at renewal, one based on an auto claim.

Sources: Regulation X, 12 CFR § 1024.17 (escrow accounts) and § 1024.37 (force-placed insurance), with their official interpretations and Appendix E; the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's mortgage servicing FAQs and guidance on payment changes; Maryland Insurance Article §§ 11-307, 27-501 and 27-607; COMAR 31.08.05.02 and 31.08.16; MIA Bulletin 16-33; and the Maryland Insurance Administration's advisory on homeowners rate increases, consumer guide to homeowners insurance, rate comparison guide, coverage review tips, guidance on insuring to value, file-and-use page and November 2024 market hardening survey. The payment example is my own arithmetic, and the premium examples come from renewals I've reviewed; clients aren't named. Checked in November 2026. This guide is general information, not legal or financial advice. Your policy and loan documents control.